This is a cute and very well done picture. The lines are smooth and for the most part, looks show accurate. I can really feel the happiness of this song in this picture, they look like their having a great time!
Vision: 5 stars, the lines are smooth and its very well done!
Originality: 5 stars, I've never seen this done before and I rarely see MLP characters in a group singing (first time seeing Spike, Applejack and Fluttershy)
Technique: 5 stars, The technique is really good, kinda goes along with the vision in my opinion!
Impact: 4 starts, *said why*
This is my first Critique, I hope I was fair and detailed!
Thanks for this! This is the first critique I've received, so one for each of us
Perhaps I'm not seeing it, but could you clarify how Impact was chosen? My reading into this is that it has slightly more impact than average (3 stars) because it puts the characters together in a not-commonly-seen activity. Is this what you had in mind?